Content starts here
AARP AARP States Advocacy

Strong support for strengthening Social Security, Medicare — But When?

Betty Bowden, of Virginia Beach
Betty Bowden, of Virginia Beach, was one of 21,000 state residents who responded to a You’ve Earned a Say questionnaire. Nearly half said major changes to Social Security should wait. — Photo by Maggie Steber

By Judi Hasson • A majority of Virginians who expressed their views on the future of Social Security and Medicare said changes are necessary to stabilize the programs, but they're split about what to do and how soon to do it.

"The share of the budget going to entitlements has to slow down. Everybody has to give a little bit, the sooner the better, to go after the problem," said retired foreign service officer Stephen Brundage, 61, of Arlington, expressing a view shared by many Virginians.

Adjusting Social Security

Seventy-one percent of the roughly 17,000 Virginia residents responding to AARP-sponsored You've Earned a Say questionnaires said the Social Security system needs adjustments, while 74 percent said the same for Medicare.

As for the timing, 27 percent of the 29,000 residents responding to an in-depth survey about Social Security said changes should be made right away, while 63 percent said changes could wait, and about 10 percent said that no changes should be made.

Asked what was Social Security's greatest financial challenge, 29 percent said higher-paid workers were not contributing enough.

More than 62,000 Virginians responded to an in-depth Medicare questionnaire: 22 percent said major changes to the health insurance system should be made now; 62 percent said lawmakers should wait a few years; and 16 percent said no changes should be made.


Betty Bowden, of Virginia Beach, was one of 21,000 state residents who responded to a You’ve Earned a Say questionnaire. Nearly half said major changes to Social Security should wait. — Maggie Steber

Betty Bowden, 65, a retired state employee from Virginia Beach, is one of those who said Congress should not delay fixing Social Security.

"I think we should start very soon to make changes. We're spending too much money and not getting in enough money," she said. "Increase the age of eligibility and cap the amount that wealthier people get."

To make sure Medicare is available for future retirees, 63 percent of respondents said a balanced approach of benefit and revenue changes will be required.

"Medicare will have to be changed because there's just not enough money," said Lorraine Bratton, 73, of Roanoke, a retired clerical supervisor at a utility company.

Asked about Medicare's biggest challenge, 36 percent said the rising cost of health care.

The responses were collected at AARP Virginia You've Earned a Say events, on a website and from questionnaires in the AARP Bulletin.

The surveys' results were presented to congressional candidates, and will be the basis for informing AARP advocacy next year as policymakers consider the programs' future.

Avoid hasty decisions

Peter Goldin, AARP Virginia associate director for advocacy, said Virginians recognize that changes are necessary, but they don't want hasty decisions to be made.

"They want something that will be sustained for future generations. They want to make sure any deal brokered is fair for those who are paying into the system now and those who are currently relying on Social Security and Medicare for retirement," he said.

When the new Congress convenes this month, it will face a number of options: an increase in the amount of income subject to the payroll tax that finances most of Social Security and some Medicare benefits; an increase in the eligibility age for both programs; a curb on cost-of-living increases for Social Security recipients; and higher Medicare premiums for higher-income enrollees.

The survey found that 65 percent of respondents said Social Security benefits should be improved, but not before the program is financially stabilized. In addition, 59 percent said everyone should get the Social Security benefits they have earned, including upper-income workers.

On Medicare, 78 percent said all future retirees should continue to get the same guaranteed coverage as beneficiaries do now, while 22 percent said beneficiaries should get a set amount of money to purchase private insurance.

Judi Hasson is a writer living in McLean,Va.

About AARP States
AARP is active in all 50 states and Washington, DC, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands. Connect with AARP in your state.